MLB Players With the Most Home Runs in ALCS History (Career & Single Season)

These players have taken advantage of the postseason spotlight in the ALCS.

Oct 11, 2024

Our trip down postseason memory lane has taken several stops over the past few weeks. It’s included looking at home-run leaders in the Division Series and NLCS (you can check out Wild Card Series leaders here, too).

We’re not done yet, though. There are two other rounds to cover. The ALCS starts on Monday, so that’s today’s topic. I’ll cover those with the most career ALCS homers first before looking at the most powerful single-ALCS performances.

Get More Content from MLB Daily Dingers!

I appreciate you letting me slide into your inbox three days a week. You can always go back and look at past newsletter issues, but that’s not the only way to get home-run content if you’re hankering for more dingers. I’ve broken down my blog content into the following digestible pages:

As always, thanks for reading and subscribing! I’m working on ways to make this subscription more valuable, fun, and engaging — I’m excited for you to see what I’m working on sometime this offseason!

Thanks for reading MLB Daily Dingers! This post is public so feel free to share it.

Jose Altuve: 12 Home Runs

Jose Altuve is another player who has found himself littered all over postseason home run leaderboards. That'll happen when your team qualifies for October and makes a deep playoff run just about every year. Through 191 plate appearances in seven trips to the ALCS, Altuve is hitting .295/.382/.560 with those 12 homers and 23 RBI.

He won 2019 ALCS MVP honors after slashing .348/.444/.652 with two homers, three RBI, and eight runs scored against the Yankees. Of course, this included his Game 6 walk-off vs. Aroldis Chapman to clinch another World Series appearance for the Astros.

Manny Ramirez: 10 Home Runs

Like it or not, Manny Ramirez is featured heavily among our postseason home run content. He's slugged the most Division Series home runs, as well as the most career postseason homers overall. Playing one step away from the World Series was ManRam's preferred time in October.

Across six ALCS appearances, Ramirez slashed .319/.422/.563 with 10 home runs and 23 RBI in 173 plate appearances. He hit exactly two homers in five of those appearances. The only time he was held homerless was in Boston's seven-game 2004 ALCS victory. Ramirez didn't homer or drive in a run during that entire series.

Bernie Williams: 9 Home Runs

Playing in the ALCS was Bernie Williams' favorite part of the postseason. His OPS went from .865 in the Division Series up to .962 in the ALCS before dipping down to .677 in the Fall Classic.

To go along with a .321/.413/.549 line with nine homers, Williams also collected 33 RBI and 31 runs scored in 189 plate appearances. He was named 1996 ALCS MVP after crushing Orioles pitching, too. Williams hit .474/.583/.947 with two homers, three doubles, six RBI, and six runs scored in that matchup.

George Brett: 9 Home Runs

It's nice to see a holdover from the 1970s and 1980s like George Brett still on this list. Of course, during his playing days, reaching the postseason typically meant going right into the League Championship Series. His nine homers came in 6 ALCS appearances. It was accompanied by a .340/.400/.728 line, 19 RBI, and 22 runs scored.

En route to winning the World Series in 1985, Brett was named ALCS MVP. He torched the Blue Jays with a .348/.500/.826 line, three homers, two doubles, five RBI, and six runs scored.

Nelson Cruz: 8 Home Runs

Nelson Cruz finds himself here despite appearing in just three ALCS matchups. That's because he went off in 2011 for the Texas Rangers against the Detroit Tigers. Virtually all of his ALCS homers came during his 2011 MVP performance. However, I'm going to save thoughts/stats on that since it'll be talked about shortly.

Overall, Cruz hit .328/.409/.845 in 66 plate appearances. Of the 19 hits he registered, 14 went for extra bases (eight homers, six doubles).

David Ortiz: 8 Home Runs

David Ortiz is one of the most clutch postseason performers of his generation. He produced a career OPS of .947 in October to go along with 17 home runs and 61 RBI in 369 plate appearances. His eight ALCS home runs are the most of any round he competed in. The same can be said about the 30 RBI he accumulated, and by a wide margin (17 RBI in Division Series, 14 in World Series).

Remember how we said the Yankees held Ramirez homerless and without an RBI in the 2004 ALCS? They didn't do the same with Big Papi. He won ALCS MVP honors after several clutch hits. He also slashed .387/.457/.742 in 35 plate appearances. Ortiz collected three homers, 11 RBI, and six runs scored during Boston's improbable comeback from a 3-0 deficit.

A total of 20 players have slugged at least five home runs in ALCS history. We've talked about the top six in detail. Here are the rest:

Jason Varitek: 7 Home Runs
Derek Jeter: 7
Alex Rodriguez: 7
Carlos Correa: 6
Jhonny Peralta: 6
Jim Thome: 6
Reggie Jackson: 6
Adolis Garcia: 5
Alex Bregman: 5
George Springer: 5
Miguel Cabrera: 5
Kevin Youkilis: 5
Sal Bando: 5
Graig Nettles: 5

Most ALCS Home Runs in a Single Postseason

Nelson Cruz, 2011: 6 Home Runs

Ah, yes -- back to Boomstick. His 2011 ALCS was just absolutely bananas. He collected eight hits in 25 plate appearances, and every single one of them went for extra bases. Outside of those six homers, Cruz also hit two doubles. His final line settled in at .364/.440/1.273 with 13 RBI and seven runs scored.

Adolis Garcia, 2023: 5 Home Runs

The Rangers pushed themselves past the Houston Astros in the 2023 ALCS to punch a ticket to the World Series. That wouldn't have happened without Adolis Garcia wreaking havoc in the middle of Texas' lineup. Garcia won Series MVP honors after hitting .357/.400/.893 with five homers and 15 RBI in 30 plate appearances.

This destruction included a grand slam in Game 6 at Minute Maid Park. It's just the third grand slam in Rangers postseason history, but the second during their title run. Mitch Garver also slugged one in the ALDS vs. the Orioles.

Randy Arozarena, 2020: 4 Home Runs

Randy Arozarena's 2020 ALCS performance was just one piece of him hitting the most home runs in a single postseason. It didn't matter which round he participated in -- Randy never stopped hitting. His lowest OPS for any round during the 2020 playoffs was in the ALCS. It settled in at 1.152 with four home runs, six RBI, and six runs scored. Oh, and he won Series MVP honors. Obviously.

Robinson Cano, 2010: 4 Home Runs

Robinson Cano hit eight postseason home runs during his career, which spanned 217 plate appearances. Four of them came in 24 plate appearances during the 2010 ALCS. In this six-game loss to the Rangers, Cano hit .348/.375/.913 with those four dingers, one double, five RBI, and five runs scored.

Josh Hamilton, 2010: 4 Home Runs

And on the other side of that 2010 ALCS matchup was Josh Hamilton. Before he won AL MVP honors that offseason, he was busy helping Texas win a pennant. He won Series MVP honors thanks to a .350/.536/1.000 line with four homers, one double, seven RBI, six runs scored, and three steals in 28 plate appearances.

This was in stark contrast to his other two rounds of postseason play that year. Hamilton posted a .311 OPS in the Division Series. That was followed by his 1.536 OPS performance against the Yankees before it dropped back down to .393 in the World Series.

Evan Longoria, 2008: 4 Home Runs

Evan Longoria played in just one ALCS and he made the most of it. He hit .259/.333/.815 against the Red Sox in 30 plate appearances. He collected eight RBI and eight runs scored. All seven of his hits went for extra bases (four homers, three doubles).

B.J. Upton, 2008: 4 Home Runs

While B.J. Upton didn't only register extra-base hits in Tampa Bay's seven-game series win over Boston, he did pretty OK. The fleet-footed outfielder hit .321/.394/.786 with four homers, one double, 11 RBI, eight runs scored, and two steals.

The only other time he appeared in an ALCS was in 2016 with the Blue Jays. He went hitless in four trips to the plate.

Jim Thome, 1998: 4 Home Runs

Cleveland couldn't take down the '98 Yankees, but it wasn't because Jim Thome didn't come to play. Across the six-game ALCS matchup, Cleveland's first baseman slashed .304/.360/.826 with four homers, eight RBI, and four runs scored. He collected just two more home runs and five RBI in two other ALCS appearances.

MLB Daily Dingers